I would recommend the hotel. It was nicely furnished, and in a beautiful location next to Arno River. Continental breakfasts were excellent. We loved the American Bar for drinks and snacks.
Lacking were several basics that we expected for this hotel and the price paid:
No ice machines
No ironing boards, or even access via housekeeping
Small (very small) television.
Plastic cups instead of drinking glasses
No wine bottle opener; had to borrow from the restaurant
Internet access was not aviailable in the room; the internet pay for minutes in the lobby was very expensive (5 Euro for 30 minutes).
Garage access was not 24 hours per day, and access via the front desk required 5 minutes wait at times.
This was a reasonable value for the money paid.
The hotel met our basic expectations, excepting the things listed previously. The personnel were very nice and accommodating.